Blog
Hidden Costs: Why NYC Buyers Without Agents Pay More
Kelly Robinson
Kelly Robinson
Buying a home in New York City without your own agent is the real estate equivalent of doing your taxes with crayons. Sure, you can technically get it done, but you’ll probably spend way more than you should and end up crying in the bathroom. Let’s break it down with hard numbers and a dash of reality.
In NYC, the listing agent works for the seller. Legally. Contractually. Spiritually. Their fiduciary duty is to squeeze every dollar out of you like you’re the last tube of Crest in a college dorm.
If you walk in unrepresented and think, “Maybe they’ll help me too?” Nope. That’s like asking your ex’s divorce lawyer for dating advice.
NYC closing costs are not just “annoying little fees.” They are real money. We’re talking 2–6% of the purchase price for resales, and 4–6% for new developments.
Highlights from the City of Surprise Fees:
Mansion Tax: 1–3.9% depending on price (starting at $1M)
Mortgage Recording Tax: ~1.8–1.925% of your loan amount
Sponsor-shifted “bonus round” fees like transfer taxes, attorney fees, and move-in charges
A good buyer’s agent negotiates these down. An unrepresented buyer just smiles politely and Venmos the developer.
Here’s the fun part: in Manhattan, the average closed price is 6.6% lower than asking.
Buyers with agents capture that. Buyers without agents? They pay full ask like it’s a Tiffany’s counter and they’re too embarrassed to ask for a discount.
NY’s Mansion Tax hits you like an ambush—1% at $1M, scaling up to 3.9% if you’re buying palace-level digs. Smart agents know how to write offers that dodge thresholds or offset the pain. Without one, you might clumsily tip your deal over the line and donate thousands to the State of New York.
Sponsors love nothing more than unrepresented buyers. Why? Because they can shift transfer taxes (1.825%), legal fees, and a menu of surprise charges onto you without pushback. With an agent, you’re more likely to get concessions: tax credits, common charge credits, free storage, maybe even a puppy (okay, not a puppy, but you get the idea).
Legal Fine Print: It’s Not Just “Sign Here”
Yes, you’ll have an attorney. But here’s the thing: attorneys fight fires; agents keep the building from burning down in the first place. Without an agent, you’re more likely to miss critical details, like building financials, hidden assessments, or that the co-op bans your beloved French bulldog. These things can cost you tens of thousands later.
Here’s the part StreetEasy and Zillow don’t put in the commercials: they do not have all the inventory. Full stop. A ton of listings, especially in the luxury market, are “coming soon,” “private exclusives,” or “office exclusives.”
For example, Compass has its own platform of private listings that never hit the open market. That means while you’re scrolling Zillow with everyone else and fighting over scraps, a good buyer’s agent is unlocking doors you didn’t even know existed.
The Co-op Board Hunger Games
If you think buying a condo is tough, welcome to the co-op board. This is where your application gets passed around by strangers who may decide you’re too loud, too broke, or too fond of Labradoodles.
A skilled broker helps you:
Assess whether you’ll realistically pass a board before wasting time and money
Package your financials and references so you look like the ideal neighbor
Position your offer not just on price, but on likelihood of approval
In plain English: your agent is the difference between “Congratulations, welcome home!” and “Sorry, the board didn’t like your vibe. Next!”
Mansion Tax: $25,000
Transfer Taxes (sponsor shifted): $36,500
Sponsor attorney fee: $3,000
Your attorney: ~$3,000
Mortgage Recording Tax: ~$30,800
With an agent: negotiate sponsor-paid transfer taxes + fees + closing credit = save $40K–$65K
Without an agent: you roast marshmallows over $65K going up in smoke.
Mansion Tax: $0 (since under $1M)
Transfer Taxes (sponsor shifted): ~$16,300
Sponsor/other fees: ~$2,500
Your attorney: ~$3,000
Mortgage Recording Tax: ~$13,860
With an agent: negotiate away transfer taxes + fees, add a small concession = save $15K–$20K
Without an agent: enjoy your surprise $20K donation to the developer’s next Tesla
NYC real estate punishes improvisation. Without a buyer’s agent, you’re not just “going it alone.” You’re paying full sticker price, swallowing sponsor costs, and leaving negotiation chips on the table like you wandered out of a casino mid-hand.
So unless your dream is to make voluntary donations to the New York State coffers and Manhattan developers, bring a buyer’s agent.
Pros
Full loyalty: they invest their time, market intel, and negotiation power in you
Better leverage: sellers and listing agents take your offers more seriously
Efficient search: your agent screens properties and connects dots you’ll miss
Stronger negotiating strategy: continuity means fewer mistakes
Cons
Less exposure if your agent isn’t aggressive enough
Personality mismatch can make the process frustrating
Commitment anxiety (but this is NYC, everyone’s in therapy anyway)
Pros
Casts a wider net if your agents cover different neighborhoods
Can feel like you’re “shopping around” for the best fit
More perspectives on value and strategy
Cons
No agent invests fully in you (why would they, if they’re competing for your loyalty?). This also means no one is truly getting to know your wants and needs. You may miss out.
Sellers see you as disorganized, which weakens your offers
Higher risk of missed deadlines, duplicated efforts, or conflicting strategies
Can sour relationships with the best brokers who don’t want to waste their time
~
In NYC, an exclusive buyer’s agent isn’t a luxury, it’s your secret weapon.
Check out our latest real estate listings from the team in more areas in New York City
Known for their attention to detail and collaborative work style, the One Global Advisory Team works to ensure their clients are expertly represented every step of the way.
CONTACT US
